这句英语说得对吗？

lily2221

Tom is in the same position as I.

000567

Tom is in the same position as I am. - 我会这么说

下面这两个应该也都可以
Tom is in the same position as me.
Tom is in the same position as mine.

晓暄

thanks

lily2221

晓暄 发表于 2013-2-12 22:29
thanks

why did you say thanks?

晓暄

谢谢你提供例句 谢谢楼上热心人的修改解释
谢谢一个很好的学习机会

lily2221

呵呵，这个是我公司一位德高望重的高级管理人员发的邮件。纯澳洲人。可能是笔误，应该是 as I am。

floraz

I or me都有人用，有争论的用法
如#2所说，如果用I 我会加上am更清楚

kidz821

000567 发表于 2013-2-11 20:50
Tom is in the same position as I am. - 我会这么说

下面这两个应该也都可以

#2 is wrong

tom's position is same as mine

hjx1000

fiddlehead

As mine 那个应该不对。
可以说 His position is same as mine.

thinker

000567 发表于 2013-2-11 20:50
Tom is in the same position as I am. - 我会这么说

下面这两个应该也都可以

Tom is in the same position as I am.
我觉得am应该变成do, 我记得前面无论是行为动词，还是表语动词都用助动词will/do/does/did来代替。（我再double check一下）
Tom is in the same position as I do.

此句as后面的从句没有宾语，就可以把do省略，变成 Tom is in the same position as I. 因此LZ原句应该是正确的。
如果有宾语的话，不能省(肯定不能省，因为还要接宾语。)



Tom is in the same position as me.
我不知道此句中的me怎么和前句对等起来。如果说The position is same to Tom as to me, 这样还可以理解。



Tom is in the same position as mine.
如果要用mine的话，此句主语必须是所有格，这样才对等，比如说　Tom's father is in the same position as mine.才行。窃以为此句不能用mine.

芒果飘香

非正式场合，本地人时常说说lazy english很普遍的吧，没必要好像抓到了 native speaker 的痛脚一样大肆宣扬一番。最重要的是能把意思表达明白清楚了，即便偷工减料也有这个水平做到拿捏得当不会造成任何歧义。我想没有人会因此怀疑其本人的英文水准，写个正式报告，发个言该严谨的时候绝不含糊，这个却是第一代移民做不到的。

conishl

只要不写下来，就是对的

basic2

同意12楼

banzhu

简单语法错误local也会有

bluesky

maybe he knew that every one knew what he was going to say, and that would make it easier .i know a lot of my local workmates like to do that.specially in oral english.
for example, some one is saying "i am going to the cinema tomorrow, you?"
i think from the above context, we all now that " you" mean what about you? or  are u going to go?
i reckon  the function of language is just for communication, as long as  we can be understood .we dont need to be linguist at all time ,do we?