NSW 2010 naplan 所有小学TOP100在170楼year3在175楼year5在204楼,公立小学排名前50在1楼51~100在202楼,YEAR

池上红衣

原帖由 mikey 于 2011-3-8 13:13 发表

个人想法不同吧，我是不会让孩子上亚裔和华人比例这么高的小学。我觉得不仅是语言的问题，更大的问题在于文化和思维方式。

赞同！总体来说我更喜欢西方式的教育体系，教育理念-崇尚自由，创造力，重过程不重结果。

[ 本帖最后由 池上红衣 于 2011-3-10 11:42 编辑 ]

cherrybrook

谢谢！

Happy猪

多谢！！！

PurpleRipples

重新校订了一些错漏.大概有5,6家新进前50.

PurpleRipples

新增:Newtown North Public School 34,   Boronia Park Public School Hunters Hill 35,  Parramatta Public School 41,  West Ryde Public School 47. 原排名中,最后3位被挤出前50.

PurpleRipples

原帖由 gogonorth 于 2011-3-7 13:03 发表


Eastwood public school Language background other than English  92%
Chatswood Public SchoolLanguage background other than English   83%
Artarmon Public school Language background other than Englis ...

这个不是太认同.我觉得还是跟ICSEA值的相关性大些.

不然西南边亚洲移民的区也很多,但是他们怎么补,学校成绩还是不行.

PurpleRipples

原帖由 iope23 于 2011-3-7 14:51 发表
LZ, have you left out concord public school , is 2315

不要着急,第一稿的时候总是有些错漏的.目前数据已经足够丰富.我会对错漏的地方进行修改. 感谢关注

PurpleRipples

原帖由 aimom 于 2011-3-7 14:52 发表

严重同感，能突破出重重包围，进入前十，实在太强大，佩服佩服

人数比较少的学校,学习成绩是相当不稳定的.这个以后我会大约分析一下.例如,去年进前10的GLADESVILLE PS, 今年已经掉到100多位去了.

还有个教会学校更夸张.2008年第一名(超过SYDNEY GRAMMAR),2009年第三名.2010年也掉到100多名以后的.(成绩我已经经过反复核实.除非MYSCHOOL的数据是错误的.)

还有PADDINGTON PS, 也有同样的问题.

所以,小的学校的生源决定了名次,与学校的教学水平反而相关性小了.

PurpleRipples

原帖由 nali 于 2011-3-7 20:47 发表


很多人就这样被叶老师给迷惑了。其实有部分几个班是临时抓来参加intensive考试或者trail test的，这些人是不参加周末补习的，但有不少考中后也被列在精英学校名单上，这样的话，其实真正的人数要远大于150以上。总人数180～2 ...

变成叶老师讨论贴了.

gogonorth

原帖由 PurpleRipples 于 2011-3-11 14:06 发表


这个不是太认同.我觉得还是跟ICSEA值的相关性大些.

不然西南边亚洲移民的区也很多,但是他们怎么补,学校成绩还是不行.

龙生龙，凤生凤。。。。。其实是受过良好教育环境优越的家庭更注重培养孩子。
但是不可否认的是亚洲移民尤其是第一代还是非常注意孩子的成绩的，这也对应来源国普遍认为不读书的体力劳动者是社会下层的看法。

ATO

我觉得主要看2011年的成绩，因为Naplan成绩好坏开始和拨款挂钩了。

PurpleRipples

原帖由 gogonorth 于 2011-3-11 14:18 发表


龙生龙，凤生凤。。。。。其实是受过良好教育环境优越的家庭更注重培养孩子。
但是不可否认的是亚洲移民尤其是第一代还是非常注意孩子的成绩的，这也对应来源国普遍认为不读书的体力劳动者是社会下层的看法。

个人认为还是学校的学习环境对孩子的影响比较大.就如同上北的地区,亚洲人的比例非常低,仍旧名列前茅. 在一个读书氛围好的学校里,小孩想不读书都很难.这也是我为什么排这个名的初衷.

PurpleRipples

另外,大家对排名有什么建议或意见,都可以提出来.我现在已经收集到400多所SYDNEY METRO的公私校的成绩.但为了排名的准确性,我准备只列出前100名公私校. 如果有筒子的学校不在排名之列,但是还是很想知道结果,可以短信.我给个大概的名次位置(就逻辑而言,这个名次如果有错漏,也只能会退后,不会提前),供大家参考.

PurpleRipples

原帖由 ATO 于 2011-3-11 14:25 发表
我觉得主要看2011年的成绩，因为Naplan成绩好坏开始和拨款挂钩了。

也许校长们会越来越重视了.

1997

鬼佬不愿意让孩子去华人孩子多的小学也就罢了，毕竟人家觉得咱们不是自己人，怕自己孩子被同化。可自己是华人也要避开华人多的学校，这是什么心理呢？不住华人区不上华人学校，即使只说英文，肤色相貌摆在那里，人家还是觉得你不是自己人。即使努力往上凑，也要人家愿意接受才行。华人的思维与其说怪，不如说对自己的文化传统缺乏基本的自豪感认同感。而对西方文化文明的崇拜又多少带些盲目性。

有感于今天上childcare 主动给华人妈妈打招呼，人家没理我，扭头冲鬼佬妈妈狂热情的真实对比。暴汗 ！！

wavesye

原帖由 fztt 于 2011-3-9 14:56 发表

Epping West 不可以。

do you know what 2nd language Epping West can choose? thanks

fztt

原帖由 wavesye 于 2011-3-11 15:52 发表

do you know what 2nd language Epping West can choose? thanks

我这就打电话帮你问。

fztt

问过了，Epping West没有第二外语。

wavesye

thanks a lot

PurpleRipples

School Name	2010 Year3+Year5	2010 Year3+Year5 Rank	Gov/NonGov
Sydney Grammar School, Edgecliff Preparatory School Paddington	5746	1	NonGov
Sydney Grammar School, St Ives Preparatory School St Ives	5744	2	NonGov
St Aloysius' College Milsons Point	5384	3	NonGov
Sydney Distance Education Primary School Stanmore	5376	4	NonGov
SCEGGS, Darlinghurst	5372	5	NonGov
Abbotsleigh	5343	6	NonGov
Artarmon Public School	5330	7	Gov
Eastwood Public School	5330	7	Gov
Pymble Ladies' College	5320	9	NonGov
Ascham School Ltd	5319	10	NonGov
Neutral Bay Public School	5307	11	Gov
Chatswood Public School	5303	12	Gov
St Philip Neri Catholic Primary School Northbridge	5303	12	NonGov
Fr John Therry Catholic Primary School	5302	14	NonGov
Hunters Hill Public School	5300	15	Gov
Beecroft Public School	5285	16	Gov
Denistone East Public School	5281	17	Gov
Queenwood School for Girls Ltd Mosman	5279	18	NonGov
Epping Public School	5274	19	Gov
Carlingford West Public School	5257	20	Gov
Beaumont Road Public School Killara	5256	21	Gov
Malek Fahd Islamic School Greenacre	5252	22	NonGov
St Mary's Preparatory School North Sydney	5246	23	NonGov
Woollahra Public School	5238	24	Gov
Meriden School Strathfield	5237	25	NonGov
Summer Hill Public School	5237	25	Gov
St Ives North Public School	5235	27	Gov
International Grammar School Ultimo	5226	28	NonGov
Epping West Public School	5225	29	Gov
St Mary's School Erskineville	5223	30	NonGov
Hurstville Public School	5222	31	Gov
Tara Anglican School for Girls North Parramatta	5218	32	NonGov
John Colet School Belrose	5216	33	NonGov
Matthew Pearce Public School Baulkam Hills	5203	34	Gov
Murray Farm Public School Carlingford	5202	35	Gov
Erskineville Public School	5193	36	Gov
Lindfield East Public School	5185	37	Gov
St Ambrose' Primary School Concord West	5185	37	NonGov
MLC School Burwood	5183	39	NonGov
Hornsby North Public School	5181	40	Gov
Our Lady of the Rosary School Kensington	5178	41	NonGov
St Raphael's Primary School South Hurstville	5177	42	NonGov
Al Noori Muslim Primary School	5175	43	NonGov
Epping Height Public School	5173	44	Gov
Montgrove College Orchard Hills	5171	45	NonGov
Presbyterian Ladies College Croydon	5164	46	NonGov
Ravenswood School for Girls Gordon	5162	47	NonGov
Holy Family Catholic Primary School	5159	48	NonGov
Lane Cove Public School	5155	49	Gov
Wenona School Ltd North Sydney	5154	50	NonGov

PurpleRipples

School Name	2010 Year3+Year5	2010 Year3+Year5 Rank	Gov/NonGov
Northbridge Public School	5151	51	Gov
Pymble Public School	5151	51	Gov
Barker College	5149	53	NonGov
Holy Cross Primary School, Woollahra,	5149	53	NonGov
John Purchase Public School Cherrybrook	5146	55	Gov
Loreto Kirribilli	5142	56	NonGov
The Emanuel School Randwick	5139	57	NonGov
Mosman Church of England Preparatory School Mosman	5137	58	NonGov
Rose Bay Public School	5137	58	Gov
Waitara Public School	5136	60	Gov
Cammeray Public  School	5131	61	Gov
Wahroonga Public School	5130	62	Gov
Kesser Torah College Dover Heights	5120	63	NonGov
Arden Anglican School	5119	64	NonGov
St Catherine's School Waverley	5119	64	NonGov
Randwick Public School	5118	66	Gov
Kincoppal-Rose Bay School of the Sacred Heart	5115	67	NonGov
Gordon West Public School	5113	68	Gov
Our Lady of the Annunciation School Maroubra	5112	69	NonGov
Middle Harbour Public School	5110	70	Gov
Trinity Grammar School Summer Hill	5106	71	NonGov
St Michael's School Daceyville	5105	72	NonGov
Manly Vale Public School	5104	73	Gov
Kambala Rose Bay	5096	74	NonGov
Newtown North Public School	5096	74	Gov
St Michael's School Lane Cove	5096	74	NonGov
Our Lady Help of Christians Catholic Primary School Epping	5093	77	NonGov
Boronia Park Public School Hunters Hill	5092	78	Gov
Westmead Public School	5092	78	Gov
Balmain Public School	5090	80	Gov
Cherrybrook Public School	5089	81	Gov
Dural Public School	5088	82	Gov
Newington College Stanmore	5088	82	NonGov
Knox Grammar School Wahroonga	5087	84	NonGov
McAuley Primary School Rose Bay	5086	85	NonGov
North Rocks Public School	5083	86	Gov
Coogee Boys' Preparatory School	5082	87	NonGov
Parramatta Public School	5079	88	Gov
Kent Road Public School Eastwood	5077	89	Gov
St Gabriel's School Bexley	5077	89	NonGov
Mount Sinai College Maroubra	5074	91	NonGov
Our Lady of the Sacred Heart School Randwick	5069	92	NonGov
The McDonald College North Strathfield	5069	92	NonGov
Blessed Sacrament School Clifton Gardens	5066	94	NonGov
Leichhardt Public School	5066	94	Gov
St Patrick's Primary School Summer Hill	5066	94	NonGov
Ermington Public School	5065	97	Gov
Bronte Public School	5062	98	Gov
Newington Public School	5059	99	Gov
St Agatha's Catholic Primary School Pennant Hills	5057	100	NonGov

粉猪妈妈

谢谢热心的楼主

有光yr 3, 公私校的排名吗

PurpleRipples

感谢加分.你的要求可以马上满足.

粉猪妈妈

原帖由 PurpleRipples 于 2011-3-12 22:42 发表
感谢加分.你的要求可以马上满足.

我是觉得，看小学质量要看３年级的，　没有oc传说之前的成绩

PurpleRipples

School Name	2010 Year 3 Sum	2010 Year 3 Rank	Gov/NonGov
Sydney Grammar School, St Ives Preparatory School St Ives	2686	1	NonGov
Sydney Grammar School, Edgecliff Preparatory School Paddington	2624	2	NonGov
Sydney Distance Education Primary School Stanmore	2581	3	NonGov
Fr John Therry Catholic Primary School	2533	4	NonGov
St Aloysius' College Milsons Point	2524	5	NonGov
St Mary's School Erskineville	2524	5	NonGov
SCEGGS, Darlinghurst	2513	7	NonGov
Our Lady Help of Christians Catholic Primary School Epping	2512	8	NonGov
Eastwood Public School	2492	9	Gov
St Michael's School Daceyville	2465	10	NonGov
St Philip Neri Catholic Primary School Northbridge	2462	11	NonGov
Our Lady of the Rosary School Kensington	2460	12	NonGov
St Ambrose' Primary School Concord West	2450	13	NonGov
MLC School Burwood	2450	13	NonGov
Ravenswood School for Girls Gordon	2450	13	NonGov
Tara Anglican School for Girls North Parramatta	2440	16	NonGov
Lindfield East Public School	2434	17	Gov
Abbotsleigh	2433	18	NonGov
Ascham School Ltd	2433	18	NonGov
Malek Fahd Islamic School Greenacre	2433	18	NonGov
Epping West Public School	2428	21	Gov
St Raphael's Primary School South Hurstville	2426	22	NonGov
Hunters Hill Public School	2425	23	Gov
St Francis Xavier's School Lurnea	2424	24	NonGov
Denistone East Public School	2419	25	Gov
St Mary's Preparatory School North Sydney	2419	25	NonGov
Beaumont Road Public School Killara	2418	27	Gov
Epping Height Public School	2416	28	Gov
St Ives North Public School	2413	29	Gov
Chatswood Public School	2411	30	Gov
Barker College	2411	30	NonGov
Epping Public School	2408	32	Gov
Pymble Ladies' College	2406	33	NonGov
Middle Harbour Public School	2404	34	Gov
Queenwood School for Girls Ltd Mosman	2403	35	NonGov
Meriden School Strathfield	2402	36	NonGov
St Catherine's School Waverley	2402	36	NonGov
St Cecilia's Catholic Primary School Balgowlah	2402	36	NonGov
Rose Bay Public School	2401	39	Gov
Carlingford West Public School	2399	40	Gov
Holy Family Catholic Primary School	2399	40	NonGov
Presbyterian Ladies College Croydon	2396	42	NonGov
West Ryde Public School	2396	42	Gov
Our Lady of Dolours Catholic Primary School Chatswood	2396	42	NonGov
Al Noori Muslim Primary School	2394	45	NonGov
John Purchase Public School Cherrybrook	2394	45	Gov
Neutral Bay Public School	2392	47	Gov
Our Lady of the Sacred Heart School Randwick	2390	48	NonGov
Artarmon Public School	2388	49	Gov
Kent Road Public School Eastwood	2385	50	Gov

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2011-3-14 12:23 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

School Name	2010 Year 3 Sum	2010 Year 3 Rank	Gov/NonGov
Lane Cove Public School	2383	51	Gov
Forestville Public School	2383	51	Gov
Berowra Christian Community School	2381	53	NonGov
International Grammar School Ultimo	2379	54	NonGov
John Colet School Belrose	2379	54	NonGov
Pymble Public School	2379	54	Gov
Brooklyn Public School	2377	57	Gov
Blessed Sacrament School Clifton Gardens	2373	58	NonGov
Beecroft Public School	2369	59	Gov
Mosman Church of England Preparatory School Mosman	2369	59	NonGov
Cammeray Public  School	2369	59	Gov
Hornsby North Public School	2366	62	Gov
Montgrove College Orchard Hills	2366	62	NonGov
Loreto Kirribilli	2366	62	NonGov
St Michael's School Lane Cove	2365	65	NonGov
Matthew Pearce Public School Baulkam Hills	2364	66	Gov
Epping North Public School	2364	66	Gov
St Bernard's School Botany	2364	66	NonGov
Pacific Hills Christian School Dural	2364	66	NonGov
Erskineville Public School	2362	70	Gov
Wahroonga Public School	2360	71	Gov
Annandale North Public School	2359	72	Gov
Manly Vale Public School	2356	73	Gov
Prouille Catholic Primary School Wahroonga	2356	73	NonGov
Hurstville Public School	2355	75	Gov
Murray Farm Public School Carlingford	2354	76	Gov
Kincoppal-Rose Bay School of the Sacred Heart	2354	76	NonGov
Lindfield Public School	2354	76	Gov
Kareela Public School	2354	76	Gov
St Brigid's Primary School Coogee	2353	80	NonGov
Sacred Heart Catholic School Pymble	2352	81	NonGov
Paddington Public School	2348	82	Gov
Northcross Christian School Ryde	2346	83	NonGov
Roseville College Roseville	2346	83	NonGov
Holy Cross Primary School, Woollahra,	2343	85	NonGov
Our Lady of the Annunciation School Maroubra	2343	85	NonGov
Truscott Street Public School North Ryde	2343	85	Gov
McAuley Primary School Rose Bay	2342	88	NonGov
Gordon West Public School	2340	89	Gov
Newington College Stanmore	2338	90	NonGov
Boronia Park Public School Hunters Hill	2337	91	Gov
Parramatta Public School	2337	91	Gov
St Gabriel's School Bexley	2337	91	NonGov
Trinity Grammar School Summer Hill	2336	94	NonGov
Leichhardt Public School	2335	95	Gov
St Kevin's School Eastwood	2334	96	NonGov
Glenmore Road Public School Paddington	2333	97	Gov
St Rose Catholic Primary School Collaroy Plateau	2332	98	NonGov
Sacred Heart School Cabramatta	2332	98	NonGov
The Emanuel School Randwick	2331	100	NonGov

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2011-3-12 23:01 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

原帖由 粉猪妈妈 于 2011-3-12 22:44 发表


我是觉得，看小学质量要看３年级的，　没有oc传说之前的成绩

加分是对贴子的肯定,不是扶云.

粉猪妈妈

哈哈，一目了然

果然，小朋友都一张白纸入学的时候，到３年级，就看出那些学校教得好了

artarmon都甩那么后面去了，　所以没考oc前，这才是选学校的精华呀．．．谢谢楼主

PurpleRipples

ARTARMON还是不错的,只是今年YEAR3的成绩有点不太理想.去年还是很高的.

粉猪妈妈

原帖由 PurpleRipples 于 2011-3-12 23:09 发表
ARTARMON还是不错的,只是今年YEAR3的成绩有点不太理想.去年还是很高的.

去年多少呢，　前２０？．．