对smh top 50中的公立小学year3的排名(更新在49楼)

PurpleRipples

	icsea	smh ranking public school	sort by ranking	sort by score	adjust
Artarmon Public School	1214	1	1	3	2
Woollahra Public School	1136	2	17	18	18
Beaumont Road Public School	1200	3	2	1	1
Carlingford West Public School	1135	4	6	7	6
St Ives North Public School	1192	5	8	10	9
Epping West Public School	1179	6	4	5	5
Summer Hill Public School	1128	7	20	22	21
Manly Vale Public School	1078	8	24	24	24
Neutral Bay Public School	1197	9	23	21	23
Gladstone Public School	956	10	5	2	3
Balmain Public School	1167	11	25	25	25
Murray Farm Public School	1178	12	13	13	13
Matthew Pearce Public School	1135	13	18	16	16
Pymble Public School	1218	14	15	15	15
Leichhardt Public School	1119	15	16	22	19
Hornsby North Public School	1126	16	22	20	21
Beecroft Public School	1228	17	21	18	20
Epping Heights Public School	1195	18	6	9	8
Denistone East Public School	1145	19	18	16	16
Eastwood Public School	1165	20	10	8	9
Lindfield East Public School	1235	21	10	11	11
Killara Public School	1216	22	8	6	7
Gladesville Public School	1121	23	3	4	3
Gordon West Public School	1212	24	14	14	14
Annandale North Public School	1185	25	12	12	12

*编制说明: 1..sort by ranking 意思是:根据各小学5项考试成绩进行排名后,对所得出的5个名次进行算数平均,然后各学校比较后得出.(purpleripples 原创,转载请注明) 2.sort by score 意思是:根据各小学5项考试成绩直接进行算数平均,然后各学校比较后得出. 3.adjust 是2个名次再次算数平均后和各学校比较后得出.

4.gladstone public 缺少写作的成绩,但是因为其他成绩都很好,所以仍旧列入.
5.有个郊区学校也在排名前50中,但学校一共51人,不具备可比性.故未列入.
6.限于篇幅,各科成绩排名未列入.

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-31 23:40 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

	icsea	smh ranking public school	ranking
Beaumont Road Public School	1200	3	1
Artarmon Public School	1214	1	2
Gladstone Public School	956	10	3
Gladesville Public School	1121	23	3
Epping West Public School	1179	6	5
Carlingford West Public School	1135	4	6
Killara Public School	1216	22	7
Epping Heights Public School	1195	18	8
St Ives North Public School	1192	5	9
Eastwood Public School	1165	20	9
Lindfield East Public School	1235	21	11
Annandale North Public School	1185	25	12
Murray Farm Public School	1178	12	13
Gordon West Public School	1212	24	14
Pymble Public School	1218	14	15
Matthew Pearce Public School	1135	13	16
Denistone East Public School	1145	19	16
Woollahra Public School	1136	2	18
Leichhardt Public School	1119	15	19
Beecroft Public School	1228	17	20
Summer Hill Public School	1128	7	21
Hornsby North Public School	1126	16	21
Neutral Bay Public School	1197	9	23
Manly Vale Public School	1078	8	24
Balmain Public School	1167	11	25

PurpleRipples

从这个排名可以剔除精英班的因素.因为没有精英班的好学校,好学生到5年级走了很多,这样一进一出,就比精英班的小学差些了.
从排名上也可以看出,在3年级的时候,没精英班的好小学,大多成绩高于有精英的小学.前10名里,只有1所精英小学,前15名里只有2所.所以,如果能够把900多所学校3年级的成绩排出来,肯定还能找出几个没精英班的好学校出来.

PurpleRipples

	reading	ranking
Beaumont Road Public School	554	1
Killara Public School	533	2
Gladesville Public School	512	3
Annandale North Public School	503	4
Artarmon Public School	496	5
Epping West Public School	495	6
Pymble Public School	495	6
Summer Hill Public School	492	8
Epping Heights Public School	490	9
Carlingford West Public School	489	10
St Ives North Public School	488	11
Gladstone Public School	487	12
Lindfield East Public School	487	12
Murray Farm Public School	485	14
Hornsby North Public School	484	15
Manly Vale Public School	483	16
Eastwood Public School	481	17
Beecroft Public School	480	18
Matthew Pearce Public School	479	19
Woollahra Public School	475	20
Balmain Public School	475	20
Denistone East Public School	474	22
Neutral Bay Public School	471	23
Gordon West Public School	469	24
Leichhardt Public School	447	25

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-29 20:57 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

	writing	ranking
Gladesville Public School	483	1
Epping West Public School	483	1
Lindfield East Public School	480	3
Artarmon Public School	479	4
Gordon West Public School	478	5
Epping Heights Public School	477	6
Carlingford West Public School	477	6
Annandale North Public School	475	8
Neutral Bay Public School	473	9
Beaumont Road Public School	472	10
St Ives North Public School	472	10
Woollahra Public School	472	10
Eastwood Public School	470	13
Pymble Public School	469	14
Murray Farm Public School	469	14
Denistone East Public School	469	14
Matthew Pearce Public School	468	17
Manly Vale Public School	464	18
Beecroft Public School	454	19
Leichhardt Public School	450	20
Summer Hill Public School	447	21
Hornsby North Public School	447	21
Killara Public School	445	23
Balmain Public School	423	24
Gladstone Public School

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-29 20:59 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

	spelling	ranking
Artarmon Public School	517	1
Gladstone Public School	517	1
Carlingford West Public School	516	3
Epping West Public School	514	4
Eastwood Public School	504	5
Murray Farm Public School	498	6
Beaumont Road Public School	497	7
Leichhardt Public School	494	8
Epping Heights Public School	491	9
Matthew Pearce Public School	491	9
Gladesville Public School	490	11
St Ives North Public School	489	12
Denistone East Public School	488	13
Lindfield East Public School	486	14
Beecroft Public School	484	15
Hornsby North Public School	483	16
Gordon West Public School	482	17
Pymble Public School	476	18
Woollahra Public School	472	19
Summer Hill Public School	469	20
Killara Public School	469	20
Neutral Bay Public School	467	22
Annandale North Public School	466	23
Balmain Public School	458	24
Manly Vale Public School	450	25

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-29 21:01 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

	grammar	ranking
Killara Public School	532	1
Leichhardt Public School	518	2
Gladesville Public School	515	3
Beaumont Road Public School	509	4
Gladstone Public School	507	5
Artarmon Public School	500	6
Epping West Public School	497	7
Gordon West Public School	497	7
Annandale North Public School	494	9
St Ives North Public School	492	10
Epping Heights Public School	490	11
Lindfield East Public School	489	12
Woollahra Public School	486	13
Murray Farm Public School	485	14
Pymble Public School	483	15
Eastwood Public School	482	16
Hornsby North Public School	482	16
Neutral Bay Public School	480	18
Denistone East Public School	479	19
Carlingford West Public School	474	20
Summer Hill Public School	474	20
Beecroft Public School	473	22
Matthew Pearce Public School	472	23
Manly Vale Public School	471	24
Balmain Public School	448	25

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-29 21:03 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

	numeracy	ranking
Beaumont Road Public School	546	1
Artarmon Public School	492	2
Eastwood Public School	490	3
Carlingford West Public School	487	4
Gladstone Public School	484	5
Killara Public School	479	6
Gladesville Public School	478	7
Epping Heights Public School	477	8
St Ives North Public School	476	9
Epping West Public School	473	10
Gordon West Public School	470	11
Annandale North Public School	470	11
Lindfield East Public School	469	13
Murray Farm Public School	469	13
Pymble Public School	467	15
Beecroft Public School	467	15
Denistone East Public School	456	17
Summer Hill Public School	456	17
Matthew Pearce Public School	456	17
Balmain Public School	454	20
Woollahra Public School	453	21
Hornsby North Public School	449	22
Neutral Bay Public School	449	22
Manly Vale Public School	444	24
Leichhardt Public School	429	25

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-29 21:04 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

以上排名比较匆忙,如有错漏请指正.

hornsay

No West Pymble public

PurpleRipples

West Pymble public 不在SMH排名前50之列,所以未列入比较.

hornsay

我看到了，排在147。

BjToSy

Around north shore, yr3 results of public school without OC class:
                                                reading                writing                spelling        grammar                numeracy
Cammeray public                        506                        467                        465                        485                        473
Willoughby public                465                        463                        450                        465                        436
Lane Cove public                491                        462                        485                        483                        460

PurpleRipples

从前50名中的公立学校看,地域主要分布在:
1.eastwood epping carlingford地区, 各2所入选,共6所.如加beecroft,7所.
2.lindfield,killara,pymble,st ives地区, 也6所.
3.下北岸:2所.
4.内西区:4所.
5.西北: 1所.
6.其他:5所.

按传统地域分:
1.上北岸:13所.
2.下北岸:2所
3.内西区:4所.
4.大西区:3所
5.东区:1所
6.北海滩:1所
7.nsw北部海岸:1所

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-30 19:35 编辑 ]

PurpleRipples

原帖由 BjToSy 于 2010-1-29 21:26 发表
Around north shore, yr3 results of public school without OC class:
                                                reading                writing                spelling        grammar                ...

Cammeray public  可以排到第14名,
Lane Cove public 大概可以到17名.

cynthia

没一个是南区的。

BjToSy

所以OC很关键。学校有一个还是两个yr5的结果就不同。OC意味着什么，华人和补习

PurpleRipples

南区排在最前面的是hurstville, 66名,如果只看3年级的分数的话:
Reading Writing Spelling Grammar & Punctuation Numeracy
443         449        481         445                                  457

比较上面的排名,基本和最后几个好学校差不多.所以66名已经比较准.

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-29 22:02 编辑 ]

digger

thanks for sharing

PurpleRipples

从2楼可以看出,前10名中,基本没变化的有6所小学.
Beaumont Road Public School  
Artarmon Public School
Gladstone Public School  
Epping West Public School  
Carlingford West Public School  
St Ives North Public School
说明以上学校教学水准和生源都比较好.

排名上升比较的大的有:
Gladesville Public School 1121 23 3          上升20名.
Killara Public School 1216 22 7                  上升15名
Epping Heights Public School 1195 18 8    上升10名
Eastwood Public School 1165 20 9            上升11名
Lindfield East Public School 1235 21 11    上升10名
Annandale North Public School 1185 25 12 上升13名
Gordon West Public School 1212 24 14     上升10名

排名下降比较厉害的有:
Woollahra Public School 1136 2 18 下降16名
Summer Hill Public School 1128 7 21 下降14名
Neutral Bay Public School 1197 9 23 下降14名
Manly Vale Public School 1078 8 24 下降16名
Balmain Public School 1167 11 25   下降14名

基本都是有英才班的学校.

当然,上面的都是好学校,是在好学校里进行的比较,您的孩子无论进上面哪一所都是不错的.

[ 本帖最后由 PurpleRipples 于 2010-1-29 22:44 编辑 ]

感恩的心

非常感谢, 收藏了.

今天正在想做个类似的比较呢, 结果LZ已经做好了哦

cetlili

我觉得这样才能说明问题，毕竟不是每个孩子都可以去OC班呀，而yr5才是关键。

jingsun

做的很好，谢谢。。。。。。

PurpleRipples

原帖由 cetlili 于 2010-1-30 07:57 发表
我觉得这样才能说明问题，毕竟不是每个孩子都可以去OC班呀，而yr5才是关键。

就上面的25所而言,这个排名搞出来很简单,只要去掉有英才班的小学就行.但是,有些有英才班的小学也很不错的,这样排名也会有些片面.

PurpleRipples

	ranking
Beaumont Road Public School	1
Carlingford West Public School	2
St Ives North Public School	3
Epping West Public School	4
Manly Vale Public School	5
Gladstone Public School	6
Murray Farm Public School	7
Pymble Public School	8
Leichhardt Public School	9
Hornsby North Public School	10
Epping Heights Public School	11
Denistone East Public School	12
Eastwood Public School	13
Lindfield East Public School	14
Killara Public School	15
Gladesville Public School	16
Gordon West Public School	17
Annandale North Public School	18

1997

非常感谢,我们这些有孩子的人也心中有数该如何选择了。lz辛苦了。

PurpleRipples

看上去北区的学生整体素质高些.

smiletolife

LZ辛苦了。谢谢。

PurpleRipples

刚查了一下,Gladstone Public School 在nsw 北部乡下,也是个很小的学校.所以可以不考虑.

PurpleRipples

就我手头还有的很多学校前几年best的考试成绩来看:
除了st ives north, manly vale, gladstone, balmain,murray farm, matthew pearce,pymble,hornsby north,gladesville, annandale north这几所学校资料不全,不好比较外,其他的在2003年到2007年的成绩也名列前茅.所以这些学校是一贯表现出色的.
个人观点,供大家参考.