Gravity的严重BUG,有物理大牛来答疑吗？

gooderic1977

当Sandra抓住Geoge的时候，不是已呈静止状态了？谁来告诉我为毛Geoge会飘走，太空没有引力的啊，只要Sandra,轻轻一拉，Geoge就应该飘回来了，难道不是吗？

不过片子绝对是好片子。很多对白仔细去捉摸也是相当有寓意的。特别是Geoge回到Sandra身边，桑问乔，你怎么回来的？乔说“long story。。。”,我觉得这里乔是被上帝派回来拯救桑的，不同意的不要喷我啊。

另外，喜欢这片子的童鞋必须看一下番外片就能明白Sandra在空间站和谁通话了

http://movie.douban.com/trailer/146487/#content

rabbitpoint

http://www.vulture.com/2013/10/astronaut-fact-checks-gravity.html

这个和真正宇航员的对话有谈及你的问题。他们还谈到了sandra的内衣，宇航员认为那是不可能的，不过看起来不错。

gooderic1977

rabbitpoint 发表于 2013-11-27 10:04
http://www.vulture.com/2013/10/astronaut-fact-checks-gravity.html

这个和真正宇航员的对话有谈及你的 ...

谢谢。专家的回答如下：

We see quite a few worst-case scenarios in the film. George Clooney ends up untethering himself from his crewmate and literally floating away into space. Is dealing with that scenario part of your training? Or does that not even come up?

Actually, I really couldn't understand the tension there. Sandra has her leg caught in some parachute rigging, and she's holding on to George by his hand. I think all he would have needed to have done would be to crawl up on her, and basically rope-climb up toward the space station. Or just lightly pull and he could have flown himself up to the space station. There would be no continuing motive force to continue to pull him away. So that physically didn't work for me.

所以就是一个严重的bug，当然还有很多其他bug，不过没有这个bug，剧情也无法继续了。