CA VS CPA，求扫盲

katherine1314

各位高人：
请问CA和CPA有什么很大的区别吗？对职业有什么不同的影响吗？
另外为什么开会计师事务所的话为什么最好要一个CA一个CPA呢？
还有就是CPA的work experience需要在什么样的公司取得呢？什么公司都行吗？还是是CPA认证的呢？如果是CPA认证的那么有那些被认证的公司清单吗？
谢谢了~

求扫盲~
(monkey33)(monkey33)

kikizhu7

http://www.cpaaustralia.com.au/cps/rde/xchg

kikizhu7

http://www.cpaaustralia.com.au/cps/rde/xchg

katherine1314

kikizhu7 发表于 2012-10-25 21:35
http://www.cpaaustralia.com.au/cps/rde/xchg

(monkey37) (monkey37) 只是主页~表示还是很疑惑~求解~高人~

fucuo

同求～

stevenhu

CA is the member of Global Accounting Alliance. If you CA qualified, you can get HKCPA membership without sitting any test.

CPA is not the member of Global Accounting Alliance, and it has a Mutual recognition agreement with HKCPA. However you must finish your CPA in Australia or HK, and you have to pass the Auditing and Financial Risk Management in your CPA program.

CA is quite popular in the world as it is the member of Global Accounting Alliance. if you work in the public practice in Australia, you better get CA. CA can be the mentor of CPA, however CPA cannot be the mentor of CA. CA program has assignment, and in the exam it has the short answer questions only. CPA does not have assignment, and in the exam it has the multiple choice questions and short answer questions.   

if you can find the CA Mentor, you should be with CA rather than CPA.

911110000

"另外为什么开会计师事务所的话为什么最好要一个CA一个CPA呢" really?? never heard about it

911110000

if you can find CA mentor, conduct CA.
Otherwise CPA

zoemry

我的理解是CA主要是在public practice firm 工作的, 例如auditing.

CPA比较大众化, 你可以在任何公司的finance department工作, 不需要一定从事publice practice.

如果不对請大家纠正喔~

911110000

zoemry 发表于 2012-10-27 07:42
我的理解是CA主要是在public practice firm 工作的, 例如auditing.

CPA比较大众化, 你可以在任何公司的fin ...

未必，CPA事务所应该比CA事务所要多吧

zoemry

911110000 发表于 2012-10-27 10:09
未必，CPA事务所应该比CA事务所要多吧

CPA对工作的要求没有CA严格吧~

911110000

zoemry 发表于 2012-10-27 09:45
CPA对工作的要求没有CA严格吧~

不清楚，CPA member 我记得至少是CA的2倍。。。还是CPA多点

zoemry

911110000 发表于 2012-10-27 11:32
不清楚，CPA member 我记得至少是CA的2倍。。。还是CPA多点

这个是实话~
我工作的地方9个人的department,几乎全部都是CPA member, 2个CPA,3个semi-qualified 的CPA.... 夸张的说,不小心一块面包砸过去,就能砸中咯~

katherine1314

stevenhu 发表于 2012-10-26 12:05
CA is the member of Global Accounting Alliance. If you CA qualified, you can get HKCPA membership wi ...

(monkey22) (monkey22) good on you. That's specifiy. However, I am still wondering if I am doing CPA can I find either CA or CPA as mentor? If i wanna go to HK, should I attend their taxation exam after my australia CPA? Thanks ~(monkey06)

katherine1314

911110000 发表于 2012-10-26 12:20
"另外为什么开会计师事务所的话为什么最好要一个CA一个CPA呢" really?? never heard about it ...

well, One of my friend told me. Her BF is CA and ask her to do CPA. The reason is CA and CPA together in a company can make advantage.  But i don't know why.

katherine1314

zoemry 发表于 2012-10-27 13:41
这个是实话~
我工作的地方9个人的department,几乎全部都是CPA member, 2个CPA,3个semi-qualified 的CPA. ...

yep, CPA is very popular in Australia. but what is semi-qualified CPA?

zoemry

katherine1314 发表于 2012-10-27 15:30
yep, CPA is very popular in Australia. but what is semi-qualified CPA?

semi-qualified 就是考过了一半的咯~

911110000

katherine1314 发表于 2012-10-27 14:26
good on you. That's specifiy. However, I am still wondering if I am doing CP ...

CPA 只要找个IFAC 的member就行，CA CPA IPA 都OK，中国的CPA也可以做 澳洲CPA的mentor

ICAA mentor 相对窄太多，基本就本土CA可以，其他零星的几个会计机构的member可以做ICAA的mentor

horseman98

911110000 发表于 2012-10-27 17:24
CPA 只要找个IFAC 的member就行，CA CPA IPA 都OK，中国的CPA也可以做 澳洲CPA的mentor

ICAA mentor 相 ...

中国的CPA可以做澳洲CPA的mentor？真的吗？哪里可以找到这个规定呀？

911110000

horseman98 发表于 2012-10-27 16:32
中国的CPA可以做澳洲CPA的mentor？真的吗？哪里可以找到这个规定呀？

你在CPA 官方网站 搜索 WHO CAN BE THE MENTOR， 里面说 IFAC 的MEMBER 都OK。然后去IFAC 查一下，中国CPA 我记得在上面

伊达政宗

首先煞风景的问一句，楼主你能考CA吗？

katherine1314

伊达政宗 发表于 2012-10-27 20:03
首先煞风景的问一句，楼主你能考CA吗？

why not? does CA need any specify requirements? I am Bachelor of Business major in Accounting in Australia. so ~~~~~~~~~~~

911110000

katherine1314 发表于 2012-10-27 22:09
why not? does CA need any specify requirements? I am Bachelor of Business major in Accounting in A ...

CA 必须找到CA MENTOR 才能开始学,而且需要你是certain position 才行，反正就最开始注册的时候比CPA麻烦

katherine1314

911110000 发表于 2012-10-27 22:12
CA 必须找到CA MENTOR 才能开始学,而且需要你是certain position 才行，反正就最开始注册的时候比CPA麻烦 ...

Certain position 有什么要求嘛？哪里有相关的说明呢？谢谢了~(monkey33)

911110000

http://www.charteredaccountants. ... /Entry-requirements

http://www.charteredaccountants. ... rience-requirements

CPA 是可以先考试 再累计工作经验的，CA 要求工作经验和考试同时的，或者是有工作经验再考试。所以刚毕业的学生考CPA的比较多

911110000

不好意思 不是certain position，是certain role

911110000

http://www.charteredaccountants. ... -experience/Mentors  只有9个会计机构的member可以做CA的mentor，CPA 只要IFAC就行，差不多100多个机构可以选择？

伊达政宗

楼主在澳洲读的书，居然还没我们在天朝的人知道得多

楼主既然是留学生，我劝你先就业，有了澳洲学历，CPAA考不考以后再看。

至于CA嘛，你不做外审基本不要那个玩意。

biling

据我所知， 考CA的一般要在CA公司里工作才行， 考CPA的可以在别的公司甚至非会计职位都可以。 CA的进入门槛比较高。

911110000

biling 发表于 2012-10-28 05:54
据我所知， 考CA的一般要在CA公司里工作才行， 考CPA的可以在别的公司甚至非会计职位都可以。 CA的进入门槛 ...

“考CA的一般要在CA公司里工作才行”,不全对。

考CA 要求公司里已经有CA了，不一定是ca accounting firm