CPA 117 2013 S1 Case 2 - Telstra

onlykun344

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-27 21:58
4g is just the new techonology, Optus roll our 4g already. Can be copied

我觉得telstra 4g 还是不好复制 first mover advantage.. 而且optus cannot access to regional areas...

除了这个你觉得还有其他strategic capabilities吗

onlykun344

jiinaustralia 发表于 2013-4-27 20:55
大家觉得gap analysis会 怎么考

同问 。。。 gap analysis 实在没有思路

onlykun344

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-27 21:41
AMTC is more relevant to temples plus global background

没太明白 global background 问题怎么涉及呢？

phoebesky

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-27 21:58
4g is just the new techonology, Optus roll our 4g already. Can be copied

I don't think it can be copied since Telstra is using the low-frequency spectrum !

carolynding

phoebesky 发表于 2013-4-28 01:35
I don't think it can be copied since Telstra is using the low-frequency spectrum !

low frequency spectrum is the feature for 3G

phoebesky

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-28 11:30
low frequency spectrum is the feature for 3G

No, no matter it is 3G or 4G ! Please take a look on the Optus then you will know the answer !

wanghui1015

gyzha2 发表于 2013-4-27 22:19
弱弱的问一句，大家有分析balanced scorecard?

bsd我有分析，但觉得不会出题。
Ansoff,Rumelt 和 Temples很明显是大头

tao-tao

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-27 21:58
4g is just the new techonology, Optus roll our 4g already. Can be copied

optus 是什么时候？ case 的第几页？ 我怎么没找到？

tao-tao

onlykun344 发表于 2013-4-27 23:33
同问 。。。 gap analysis 实在没有思路

我已经放弃GAP 了， 总有问题准备不到的， 如果考了就海阔天空吧， 实在想不出来

TANDC

怎么用Rumelts分析Telstra呀大家给点idea吧， 谢谢了！

phoebesky

tao-tao 发表于 2013-4-28 12:11
optus 是什么时候？ case 的第几页？ 我怎么没找到？

on P.15

carolynding

tao-tao 发表于 2013-4-28 12:11
optus 是什么时候？ case 的第几页？ 我怎么没找到？

pg15 optus那段里第二段，2012 sep roll out 了

phoebesky

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-28 12:43
pg15 optus那段里第二段，2012 sep roll out 了

and Optus cannot extend its 4G network into regional areas because it don't have suiable low-frequency spectrum available ! that's why it can't be copied currently.

Aqi1987

phoebesky 发表于 2013-4-28 13:00
and Optus cannot extend its 4G network into regional areas because it don't have suiable low-frequ ...

correct, and it is not better than telstra's 4g

Sophia_Bao

请问大家的Rumelts是怎么准备的，internal consistency 应该写什么呢？ Improving Customer Service?

wjchen18

Temples analysis里的environment 和 society 有东西可写么？ 毫无头绪啊
是每个都要写么 还是有些文章里没提到可以不写啊？好疑惑

Sophia_Bao

sm375 发表于 2013-4-26 12:20
这个CASE的RUMELT我只分析了4G,大家觉得还有其他的option需要分析的吗？

你好，我也是分析的4G， 可以互换吗？bchong001234@gmail.com

carolynding

phoebesky 发表于 2013-4-28 13:00
and Optus cannot extend its 4G network into regional areas because it don't have suiable low-frequ ...

agree cannot copy in short term, I argue such fist move advantage does not last long

Sophia_Bao

Aqi1987 发表于 2013-4-26 17:11
谢谢！

我的分析是strategy放在4g上面写，19页，telstra第一个开放24小时客服，算system，建立一个new d ...

你好，请问Rumelts怎么准备的，互换一下可以吗？ bchong001234@gmail.com

tao-tao

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-28 12:43
pg15 optus那段里第二段，2012 sep roll out 了

谢了， 谢了。

tao-tao

大家不要都看得这么仔细， 搞得我心里怕怕的。
我觉得真到了考试， 不会的， 分就丢了吧， 什么都准备的很好， 那都考 Hd了， 毕竟pass 就够了

nighterxxx

HI everyone,

Just want to discuss about the the type of businiss transformation on Telstra.

A. Fine tuning B. Increamental adjustment C Modular transformation.

I would choose B Increamental adjustment but not quite sure if it is related to C Modular transformation.

Can some one please advise on it?

Thx

Aqi1987

Sophia_Bao 发表于 2013-4-28 15:46
你好，请问Rumelts怎么准备的，互换一下可以吗？

sorry这部分还没准备，其实只要bussiness strategy, external什么的总结出来，基本完成一半了

phoebesky

carolynding 发表于 2013-4-28 15:45
agree cannot copy in short term, I argue such fist move advantage does not last long

I understand but the case fact doesn't mention any future circumstances so we should conclude it can't be copied.
.
.

shadow17

想請問一下, module 3內的 "are u able to assess how the organization has performed to date in meeting its objectives based on the given facts" 和 module 6內的"how has the organization performed in its implementation of the strategy" 都是在問同一样問題嗎?

Sophia_Bao

Aqi1987 发表于 2013-4-28 15:52
sorry这部分还没准备，其实只要bussiness strategy, external什么的总结出来，基本完成一半了 ...

我比较纠结internal consistency, 希望你准备好了可以交流一下，

Kevin2013

nighterxxx 发表于 2013-4-28 15:51
HI everyone,

Just want to discuss about the the type of businiss transformation on Telstra.

I feel it should be the fine tuning: as the strategy is on-going refinement of existing strategy and processes, lowing the price to gain market share since 2009 and raise it up again this year to improve profit margin. While, incremental adjustment might be appliable, as the roll over of 4G network is a distinct change. Because the fixed line is declining, the 3G market is mature, and the 4G is starting out.

While, overall, I believe the style of transformation of Telstra is fine tuning.

Kevin2013

Anyone who can share some ideas with how modular 6 will be examed in the Telstra case?

I find the 7s and 8 steps is very hard to apply as a lot of info are not available in the material.

Only can think about the life cycle of Telstra is towards mature, the leadership suppose to be caretaker, especially with the roll out of 4G.

大家加油！明天好运。

Aqi1987

Sophia_Bao 发表于 2013-4-28 16:14
我比较纠结internal consistency, 希望你准备好了可以交流一下，

我做的evaluation，你看看哦，有啥不对的请多指教

Evaluations:

Australia has a great technology base to establish 4g as it is now 3rd highest penetration in 3g handsets, as the technology develops, the usage shifts from traditional mobile voice communication to data transmission services, people’s demand on the messaging services is increasing as well as data consumption trigged by innovation and widespread distribution of smart phones and cheap data price. Since 4g is significantly faster in data transmission than 3g and provides crystal clear voice communication, rolling out 4g is consistency with industry trend.

Telstra’s business strategy focuses on differentiation, providing premium-priced services to customer and secure market leader position in foreseeable years, rolling out the 4g will make them stand out from rivals, and hence will highly likely for them to lead the Australian mobile telecommunications carrier industry.

Telstra’s revenue has grown constantly from 2005 to 2012 and is predicted to continue, and Telstra is high-cash-flow corporation, so that they will have enough resources to implement the 4g.

Providing 4g will give them long-term advantage as mentioned above, it add value to the current services, better than Optus as the license issue they are facing.

donnie

Kevin2013 发表于 2013-4-28 17:34
Anyone who can share some ideas with how modular 6 will be examed in the Telstra case?

I find the  ...

但总体来说会不会是surgeons？