Why I hate ASP.net (ZT)

典

Why I hate ASP.net
http://www.gamerswithjobs.com/node/50020

Why not just trust the programmer to know how the web works? They had to with classic ASP, and need to with PHP, Python, Ruby, and other modern web scripting languages. I find it rather insulting that Microsoft feels that they need to hand-hold a desktop programmer through the web programming environment. It's not just training wheels, it's converting the bicycle to a motorized four-wheeler because they think their programmer is used to driving a car. Well, guess what, I know how to ride a bike and I don't want or need that "help."

The bottom line is this: Why does it have to be so complicated? Don't even get me started on their half-assed "AJAX" add-on. If you're a web developer, all of this crap just gets in the way. The web is the web, there's no need to pretend it's a desktop application. Trying to force it to be one is counter-productive and has wasted countless hours of my life.
...

Back to ASP.net: I really wish the old forms way of doing things would just be abandoned, or that MVC would be forked into an entirely new product. It's so different and a complete reboot of ASP. That can be frustrating when features that *should* already exist don't, but for the most part your bases are covered. I just discovered the PagedList class which has been a huge help in displaying search results. Again, this should be in the default framework, but so it goes.

典

说实话，以前的asp.net我一直都不喜欢，hate
觉得MVC又不错了，

无视

典，很高兴你现在不怎么hate asp.net了

Server side programming通过近10年的发展是一个很成熟的领域，business不必花很多的精力就能有很好的解决方案。

client progamming这边基本上属于战国时代，很多东西还在很初级的探索阶段，解决方案的选取不光取决于技术本身，还取决于社区的倾向和个人的影响力，而且开发过程远远没有server那边那么正规，没有现成的流程可以遵循，而且dev需要更多这方面的修养。

单讲干活的话，两个都不可缺，但两者相比，server side的东西更重要些，team中有1-2个client这边相对的好的人就可以出活了，现在的趋势是对client side programming的要求也是越来越高了，更偏向于个别职位的需求。但要跟serverside tech的要求相提并论，还需要些时日。

bmatt

做了几个月的MVC项目，觉得还是MVC更地道一些。。赞同楼主的观点

flyspirit

ASP.NET的webform, 现在回想起来就是MS捆绑windows developer继续用它的web development solution的一个策略， 一个阴谋， 一个骗局。

无视

原帖由 flyspirit 于 2011-12-9 10:33 发表
ASP.NET的webform, 现在回想起来就是MS捆绑windows developer继续用它的web development solution的一个策略， 一个阴谋， 一个骗局。

trend moves to flip side every 5 years and people really enjoy it,who knows

kuxxc

无语了。。。让我能够温饱就是好产品。支持 asp.net！