请教大神，为什么AFL没有拖延时间？

dpblue

半懂不懂看AFL中，今晚刚看完一场惊魂动魄的比赛，比赛还剩1分钟的时候，Melbourne领先GWS1个球多一点，然后被GWS打入1球，导致最后30秒只领先半个球，那30秒也是门前风声鹤唳，GWS差点绝杀之。

这种情况下，如果是足球比赛，那一定是后卫直接倒来倒去，或者把球带到角旗的位置不动，或者干脆动不动倒地装死，各种拖延时间的办法都有。但我看到Melbourne完全没有要拖延时间的意思，如果说hand ball会被人抢，那么用脚在几个后卫直接踢来踢去对方根本没法上来抢的吧？这一分钟很容易浪费掉的啊，是因为有规则限制吗？

ar10

之前老外同事评价的“”Aussie rules, No rule".
AFL 又称Aussie rules

逆鳞龍

如果是足球比赛，那一定是后卫直接倒来倒去

你这是老规则了，现在这些年规则强调必须进攻，否则就会以拖延时间给牌。

AFL，Rugby League，Rugby Union等英式橄榄球和澳洲规则橄榄球都是进攻性运动，当你不进行攻城拔地，就很可能被对方抢夺，那时候就不是你领先半球而是对方反超了。

pinkswan

AFL: rules are there are no rules
Peter FitzSimons (a former national representative rugby union player)

FOR no good reason other than I've been thinking about it for months, let's hear it for Aussie rules. After a decade or so of bagging it, and another decade of feeling luke-warm at best, I have finally come to the conclusion that its beauty lies in the fact that it really is the most quintessentially Australian game of all.

1.Despite the name, there don't really seem to be any rules to speak of. At least not very complex ones whereby the only person that truly understands them is the umpire. As a people we've never been too big on rules, and this game isn't either.

2.Most other sports, and particularly union and league, have an obsession with whether a player, or the ball, did or did not go beyond the boundary line. Not Aussie rules. Even in grand finals no one seems to give a stuff as they scamper right along the line. "Close enough is good enough." Keep going!

3.Every other football code has an offside rule. Not Aussie rules. You're an Australian mate. Go where you damn well please!

4. As far as the scoring system goes, every other football code says you either did score, or you didn't. Not Aussie rules, the true sport of "Have a go!" If you get the ball between the two big posts, beauty, take six points. But if you just miss, no worries. You had a go, and you had a bloody good go, so take a point anyway!

dpblue

逆鳞龍 发表于 2020-9-16 13:42
你这是老规则了，现在这些年规则强调必须进攻，否则就会以拖延时间给牌。

AFL，Rugby League，Rugby Uni ...

足球比赛可以通过后卫把球传来传去拖延时间，这种情况肯定不会给牌

不清楚AFL是否会给牌，所以有此一问。即使AFL是进攻性运动，后卫用脚踢的方式传来传去也是几乎不可能把球断下来的

逆鳞龍

dpblue 发表于 2020-9-18 12:25
足球比赛可以通过后卫把球传来传去拖延时间，这种情况肯定不会给牌

不清楚AFL是否会给牌，所以有此一问 ...

无意义倒脚是给拖延时间的黄牌的。现在强调必须进攻

dpblue

逆鳞龍 发表于 2020-9-18 14:53
无意义倒脚是给拖延时间的黄牌的。现在强调必须进攻

足球比赛会因为后场倒脚给黄牌？不可能吧？我只知道装死或者开球慢要吃黄牌，倒脚吃牌真没听说过

逆鳞龍

dpblue 发表于 2020-9-18 16:30
足球比赛会因为后场倒脚给黄牌？不可能吧？我只知道装死或者开球慢要吃黄牌，倒脚吃牌真没听说过 ...

这些年已经规则改成了进攻足球了，一来增加可看性，二来增加公平性。

Thyme

歪一下楼，今年因为疫情都关在家，那AFL总决赛的公共假日（维洲）还有吗？

rockbox

lz还是看的少，afl在自己后场倒脚是最危险的踢法，球踢到对方五十米区才最安全。
都是踢人盯人，一旦盯住mark很难，不能mark就起不到拖延作用，随时被tackle白送对方free kick，和soccer不一样啊，橄榄球随机率太高，很难掌控精确落点方向。所以节奏非常快，所以澳洲人看惯Footy的，喜欢soccer很少。对场上稍有软弱表现的球员，不管敌我，都常会骂一句，go play soccer...
最后几分钟拿到mark一般会拖延几秒钟，但中后场一般要求5-10秒出脚，前场有大概二十秒出脚。
其实Footy技巧很简单(这一点我是非常鄙视的)，几乎就是纯粹追求更快更高更强，当然意识好也很重要。