CPA vs CA

chrisliu

PS: Advanced English is a must for a professional CPA. Please improve. Unfortunatelly, you have limited knowlege and resouces regarding professional bodies.

Haroldliu

原帖由 chrisliu 于 2009-10-1 15:14 发表



Hey, I dont need you to tell me anything. You are a member of CPA does not mean you are a CPA, only if you got a CPA certification then you can call yourself a CPA. Please be clear of that. If y ...

It does not matter whether you think I am qualified CPA or not. It is your business. Who care?

chrisliu

大哥，英文，注意英文。上下文都不通了。
It's none of my business. Hehe  Who cares?

Haroldliu

原帖由 chrisliu 于 2009-10-1 15:21 发表
PS: Advanced English is a must for a professional CPA. Please improve. Unfortunatelly, you have limited knowlege and resouces regarding professional bodies.

I am quite interested in meeting with you. Where do you live? Can we talk somewhere personally? I want to share my limited knowledge with you. I am in Melbourne.

chrisliu

I am not interested in you at all. Sorry budy.

[ 本帖最后由 chrisliu 于 2009-10-1 15:39 编辑 ]

holyplague

有张纸叫假证

suel

原帖由 RobF 于 2009-10-1 09:30 发表


Oh, really? Then it's hard for me to understand why 2 colleagues of mine who have got AICPA (the CPA USA you are talking about) can only get 80-90% of my pay. Both of them are older than me and ha ...

我不知道倒底哪个更加值钱,不过如果你说他们AICPA拿的工资比你少,他们是否在澳洲工作?如果是,那么很明显,可能他们的经验不够你好,还有就是地方性,总觉得本地的CA,CPA强人一筹.你应该比较同样工作经验的AICPA在美国或者其他地方拿的工资同本地的CA在澳洲拿的.

另外,我记得我当初看过CPA的申请资料,ACCA是不可以直接转的,甚至考试都不能免(不知道现在是否还是这样)不过印度的CPA倒是可以.那么是否代表印度的CPA比ACCA更加质量高?

RobF

他们是否在澳洲工作?

Yes. Same office in the same city.

如果是,那么很明显,可能他们的经验不够你好

All of us are from overseas actually. I came from China 3 years ago. One  came 1.5 years ago and the other one came 4 years ago.  None of us are local and none of us have got local degree.

我不知道倒底哪个更加值钱

To be honest, I do not know either and do not really care. I know their salary simply because I did forecast which means...hehe. And I will never try to compare which qualification is better which is not cos I think one qualification is enough. I'm tired of studying at the moment. Will do CFA later though.

When I mentioned the above information, I was trying to prove that AICPA was not necessarily better than others. Qualification is just qualification. As simple as that.

你应该比较同样工作经验的AICPA在美国或者其他地方拿的工资同本地的CA在澳洲拿的.

I've got no idea about how much AICPA can get in U.S because I do not cover anywhere outside Asia Pacific so... Plus, I'm not going U.S so I did not do any research about the pay there.

Alright alright, I'm not the ppl who is try to say which qualification is better which is not. All I want is that we have got no discrimination. Do whatever suits you the best.

Maybe I'm a small potato but I do appreciate that ppl can talk to me properly

paladinyw

原帖由 Haroldliu 于 2009-10-1 14:58 发表
At least I know more than you little RobF.
I am member of ACCA/CICPA/AICPA, CPA Austrlia.
Your stupid nut.

唉，也不知道是真的假的。如果是真的，也就不难理解这个行业的鱼龙混杂了。

astina

原帖由 RobF 于 2009-10-1 16:23 发表
他们是否在澳洲工作?

Yes. Same office in the same city.

如果是,那么很明显,可能他们的经验不够你好

All of us are from overseas actually. I came from China 3 years ago. One  came 1.5 years ago an ...

本来就没什么哪个比哪个更好更值钱的，钱钟书在围城里借书中人物之口说过：上大学就好比出天花，人都需要出一次，接下去就不用念念不忘老挂在嘴上了

chrisliu

本来不想说了，多嘴两句回复小桑子同学。

我觉得ROB同学被你引用的话，确实欠妥。不过很像是堵气不过说出来的。其实AICPA， CPA Australia，还是其他都好。在我看来价值是一样的。都是不同的会计职业团体。只要真正通过考试，满足实际工作经验的，都是专业人士。

CPA Australia也是世界前6大会计师协会之一。在IASB还是有话语权的。其他还有美国的，加拿大的，欧盟的，英国的，新加坡，香港等等。这几个国家的会计师基本是互认的。就是有些regulation, taxation等等的不同，所以如果是某一国的CPA or CA去认证的另外一个国家工作，在工作经验互认的前提下，还是要再考当地的一两门课才能拿到当地的执业证。

会计师不存在哪里的文凭更强，最重要的是工作经验。既不要把欧美的看的很牛比，也不要妄自菲薄认为澳洲的很差。这个行业特别讲究工作经验和人格魅力的。

自从2000年澳洲开始执行国际会计准则以后，互认的就更多了。具体请参考大学Advanced Accounting Theory这门课的内容。印度因为执行英国的会计准则，所以和澳洲也是互认的。但是不是全免，还是要考一门考试的。具体考哪门我不知道，正好隔壁公司的阿叉会计在考，我可以去问问。

希望大家和谐和谐。国庆快乐:)

[ 本帖最后由 chrisliu 于 2009-10-1 16:34 编辑 ]

RobF

原帖由 astina 于 2009-10-1 16:27 发表

本来就没什么哪个比哪个更好更值钱的，钱钟书在围城里借书中人物之口说过：上大学就好比出天花，人都需要出一次，接下去就不用念念不忘老挂在嘴上了

lol...yeah, something like that. This line is a good one. I'll remember it.

RobF

原帖由 chrisliu 于 2009-10-1 16:33 发表
本来不想说了，多嘴两句回复小桑子同学。

我觉得ROB同学被你引用的话，确实欠妥。不过很像是堵气不过说出来的。其实AICPA， CPA Australia，还是其他都好。在我看来价值是一样的。都是不同的会计职业团体。只要真 ...

en...it was 堵气话

小财务

原帖由 Haroldliu 于 2009-10-1 14:58 发表
At least I know more than you little RobF.
I am member of ACCA/CICPA/AICPA, CPA Austrlia.
Your stupid nut.

So many membership!  How much membership fee are you paying??? lol
Is company paying for you?  If not, at least it's tax deductible. hehehe

suel

原帖由 chrisliu 于 2009-10-1 14:33 发表
本来不想说了，多嘴两句回复小桑子同学。

我觉得ROB同学被你引用的话，确实欠妥。不过很像是堵气不过说出来的。其实AICPA， CPA Australia，还是其他都好。在我看来价值是一样的。都是不同的会计职业团体。只要真 ...

我觉得大家的语文水平都不太好了.可能这里待太久了.还是我的语文表达能力实在太差?我的意思本来就是无所谓什么证书是否更加值钱,只是觉得光从拿不同证书人在澳洲的收入来做比较可能不是很合理,毕竟每个证书都是有他自己的优势.当然如果从长期在澳发展,可能本地证书更加好一点,但是如果要考虑今后回国啊,去欧洲啊,美国发展,可能其他证书更加有优势.
说实在,自己拿了N个证书,但是不觉得拿到证书后对我的以前工作和现在�